Right here’s Why Rural Hospitals Are Shutting Down Extra Shortly In These States

Michael Ollove

In crime novelist Agatha Christie’s largest hit, “And Then There Had been None,” friends at an island mansion die suspicious deaths one after one other.

So you possibly can forgive Jeff Lyle, an enormous fan of Christie’s, for evaluating the 36-bed group hospital he runs in Marlin, Texas, to a type of unlucky friends. In December, two close by hospitals, one virtually 40 miles away, the opposite 60 miles away, closed their doorways for good.

The closings had been the newest in a pattern that has seen 21 rural hospitals throughout Texas shuttered up to now six years, leaving 160 nonetheless working.

Lyle, who’s CEO, can’t assist questioning whether or not his Falls Neighborhood Hospital will probably be subsequent.

“Most assuredly,” he replied when requested whether or not he may envision his central Texas hospital going below. “We’re not utilizing our reserves but, however I can see them from right here.”

It’s not simply Texas: Practically 100 rural hospitals in the USA have closed since 2010, in keeping with the Heart for Well being Providers Analysis at College of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. One other 600-plus rural hospitals are susceptible to closing, in keeping with an oft-cited 2016 report by iVantage Well being Analytics.

Texas had probably the most hospitals in peril of closing (75), the well being metrics agency stated. And Mississippi had the biggest share of hospitals in danger (79 p.c).

Neither state has expanded Medicaid eligibility to extra of its low-income residents below the Inexpensive Care Act, often known as Obamacare. The truth is, the closures and at-risk hospitals are closely clustered within the 14 states that haven’t expanded.

A 2018 research within the journal Well being Affairs discovered that the speed of closures of rural hospitals elevated considerably in non-expansion states after 2014, when states started implementing the growth. On the identical time, closure charges decreased in growth states.

These state choices to not increase have disadvantaged rural hospitals, which already function with the slimmest of margins, of assets that could possibly be the distinction between survival and closure.

That’s the reason Lyle and directors of different rural hospitals in Texas and different non-expansion states are so adamant about their states becoming a member of the ranks of people who have expanded.

“It could imply a good variety of folks we see who haven’t any insurance coverage would have insurance coverage,” Lyle stated. “And for us, a greenback is healthier than no greenback.”


In Texas, growth would make 1.2 million extra folks eligible for Medicaid, in keeping with a 2018 Kaiser Household Basis evaluation. An City Institute research in 2014 estimated that not increasing Medicaid would deprive Texas hospitals of $34.three billion in federal reimbursements over 10 years.

With out that cash, many rural hospitals in Texas and different non-expansion states have closed obstetrics items and different costly providers, forcing sufferers to journey lengthy distances to hunt therapy on the next-closest hospital, which is typically hours away.

By shedding these providers, the hospitals diminish their purpose for present, stated Maggie Elehwany, head of presidency affairs and coverage for the Nationwide Rural Well being Affiliation.

The workplace of Republican Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and the newest Republican chairmen of the well being committees within the Texas legislature (the legislature has but to make committee assignments for the present legislative session), Sen. Charles Schwertner and Rep. 4 Worth, didn’t return calls requesting remark for this story.

One other rural hospital in Texas, Goodall-Witcher in Clifton, which additionally operates two group well being clinics and a nursing room, risked closing till residents of Bosque County voted in November to create a hospital taxing district.

“I’m not saying we’d have closed the day after the election,” stated Adam Willmann, the hospital’s CEO, “however I don’t know the way for much longer we may have gone.”

The extra taxes will convey the hospital an estimated $2.5 million a yr and maybe take it out of the crimson, however they gained’t essentially elevate Goodall-Witcher out of economic peril, Willmann stated.

“Medicaid growth,” Willmann stated. “That is likely one of the key issues we may do to assist us take care of the powerful monetary calls for we face.”

However not everybody believes Medicaid growth is the reply to the issues dealing with rural hospitals. “Medicaid is as prone to prop up inefficient and wasteful hospitals as anything,” stated Michael Cannon, director of well being coverage research on the libertarian Cato Institute.

Burden of uncompensated care

As envisioned by the ACA when it handed Congress in 2010, growth states would lengthen advantages to all adults — together with childless adults — whose earnings was at or beneath 138 p.c of the federal poverty line. (In 2019, that may be a median particular person earnings of $12,140, relying on the state.)

Initially, the federal authorities paid 100 p.c of the well being care prices of the growth inhabitants. The federal share falls to 90 p.c in 2020. States must make up that distinction on their very own, a prospect that has stored some states from increasing Medicaid. 

So far, 36 states plus Washington, D.C., have expanded Medicaid. By 2017, growth below the ACA had lined 17 million new enrollees. Roughly one other four million folks would qualify within the remaining states, in keeping with a 2018 Kaiser report.

As a substitute, lots of these low-income residents stay uninsured or underinsured in plans with excessive deductibles and copayments.

However that doesn’t imply folks don’t obtain well being care. With out medical insurance, low-income individuals are much less prone to get preventive care, which regularly ends in worsening well being situations that continuously convey them to hospitals the place they’re assured therapy. Below federal regulation, hospitals should stabilize and deal with anybody displaying up on the emergency room, no matter their means to pay.

Rural hospitals, like their city counterparts, are compelled to soak up these prices. However not like greater hospitals, their affected person volumes and working margins are so low that “uncompensated care” burdens might be crippling.

As an illustration, Willmann stated his hospital’s uncompensated tab final yr was about $four.2 million, or 11 to 12 p.c of his total funds.

In accordance with the Oklahoma Hospital Affiliation, the state’s rural hospitals carried about $170 million in unhealthy debt from charitable care and sufferers’ unpaid payments. 5 rural hospitals have closed within the state since 2016.

‘99 different wounds’

Many directors of rural hospitals are fast to say that Medicaid growth alone is not going to resolve their monetary issues. Rural hospitals confronted steep challenges lengthy earlier than the ACA.

Rural Individuals are typically older, in poorer well being and fewer insured than these dwelling elsewhere, the latter leading to a better share of uncompensated look after rural hospitals. Due to declining populations in rural areas, hospitals there usually have empty beds, which implies much less income.

“It’s been a protracted, gradual bleed,” stated Fred Blavin, a well being coverage knowledgeable on the City Institute.

Automated federal funds cuts starting in 2013 (generally known as sequestration) decreased Medicare reimbursements, that are a very vital income for hospitals. Congress has reduce on the quantity hospitals can deduct for unhealthy debt. Congress, in its funds tightening, decreased different types of help to rural hospitals as nicely.

“You may put a Band-Help on, however you continue to have 99 different wounds,” Willmann stated.

Elehwany, of the Nationwide Rural Well being Affiliation, stated that rural communities the place hospitals are compelled to shut would possibly have the ability to meet residents’ well being wants by opening a brand new pressing care facility or maternal care middle.

The lack of rural hospitals not solely means sufferers having to journey longer distances to the subsequent medical suppliers, however the closures can also usually have a crippling impact on the native financial system.

Goodall-Witcher Hospital is the biggest employer in Bosque County. “Our payroll is larger than the county’s total funds,” Willmann stated. “Are you able to think about what it could do to this county to lose $9 million from the financial system a yr?”

A Well being Providers Analysis journal report discovered that when a rural space’s solely hospital closes, earnings per capita falls by four p.c and unemployment rises by 1.6 p.c.

Willmann was relieved voters in his district supported the measure to create a hospital taxing district, however he acknowledged that it wasn’t a superb deal for his county’s taxpayers. Their federal taxes assist pay for the growth in different states however not in Texas.

“Mainly, you’re asking them to pay twice,” he stated.

Rural hospital officers seem to not have the slightest hope that the deep crimson Texas legislature and governor will get behind growth.

“There isn’t a probability of Medicaid growth in Texas within the close to time period,” stated John Henderson, CEO of the Texas Group of Rural & Neighborhood Hospitals.


Stateline residence web page

Join unique state coverage reporting and analysis